The Ultimate Non-Toxic Baby Registry Guide

A Thoughtful, Organic List from a Mama of Five

I’ve learned to simplify, choose wisely, and avoid toxic overload. Babies don’t need much—but they deserve the best start. So I’ve put together a non-toxic registry list that focuses on safe, organic, low-toxin, and high-quality essentials.

What I Look for in a Non-Toxic Registry

It’s frustrating that most baby products in the U.S. are poorly regulated, with toxic chemicals hidden behind words like “fragrance” or “flame resistant.” That’s why I always look for these keywords and certifications:

✅ Keywords & Certifications I Trust:

Organic
GOTS (Global Organic Textile Standard)
GOLS (for latex and mattresses)
Made Safe Certified
Greenguard GOLD (especially for furniture and mattresses)

🚫 Ingredients & Materials I Always Avoid:

PFAS (forever chemicals)
Fragrance (even “natural”)
Flame retardants
Formaldehyde
VOCs (off-gassing from foam, paint, plastics)
Phthalates, parabens, heavy metals, synthetic fibers
Chlorine bleach, petrochemicals, polyurethane foam

Doing this homework protects baby’s skin, hormones, immune system, and long-term health. It’s 100% worth it.

{This post contains affiliate Amazon links. That means I may earn a small commission—at no extra cost to you—if you choose to make a purchase through one of these links. I only recommend products I genuinely love, have personally used, or have thoroughly researched and would confidently use for my own family.}

Where Baby Sleeps

All of my newborns have ended up sleeping right next to me. With my first baby, we tried the whole “nursery and crib” setup—but truthfully, it wasn’t fun. I was constantly getting up, half-asleep, and it just felt unnatural being so far from him. Eventually, we ditched the crib and started co-sleeping safely, and it made all the difference—for both of us.

That said, if I were to choose a crib and mattress now, I would 100% go with the non-toxic options below. Baby’s sleep space should be cozy, breathable, and free of chemicals like flame retardants and VOCs. These brands check all the boxes for a clean, peaceful start.

1. Sleep & Nursery

Baby's sleep is sacred—and so is the environment they rest in. Here are my top clean, breathable, and chemical-free essentials.

Organic Crib Mattress – Naturepedic Organic Breathable Mattress (GOTS & GOLS certified)
Crib sheets – Waterproof Organic cotton; KeaBabies, Burt's Bees

How I Started Using Cloth Diapers

I never planned to use cloth diapers. It honestly felt overwhelming—washing them, figuring out the types, folding, the whole thing. But when a good friend of mine offered to give me her entire stash, I said yes mostly out of curiosity (and let’s be real, free baby gear is always a win!).

Once I started using them, I was surprised by how easy it actually was. I didn’t have to research every brand or build a system from scratch—it was all there, ready to try. And the best part? No more mystery chemicals or plastic right against baby’s skin.

Cloth diapers felt softer, cleaner, and more natural. Plus, I loved not having a trash can overflowing with disposables. Now, even with five kids, I still use cloth at home. It saves money, reduces waste, and just feels good. I'm not 100% cloth all the time, and that's okay. But I’m really grateful for that friend who helped me start without pressure or perfection.

When I had my first baby, I didn’t even think twice about baby wipes—I just used whatever was at the store. Then one of my kids developed a stubborn rash that wouldn’t go away, no matter how much diaper cream I used. That’s when I discovered WaterWipes. They’re made with just two ingredients—water and a drop of fruit extract. That’s it. No fragrance, no weird chemicals, nothing to irritate delicate skin. They are think and soft. I’ve used them for every baby since, and they’re the only wipes I trust to use from day one.

2. Diapering

Cloth:

Esembly Organic Cloth Diaper System – leakproof and stylish
Cloth-eez Organic Prefolds – ultra-absorbent, budget-friendly
Disana Wool Covers – lanolize naturally and breathe

Disposables safer (PFAS-Free):

Dyper
Bambo Nature (European-made, no chlorine)
Kudos

Wipes:

WaterWipes – 99.9% water + fruit extract (These are the only wipes that we use!)
Reusable Cloth wipes

Diaper balm:

Earth Mama Organic Diaper Balm
Handmade Whipped Tallow Balm - Organic, Moisturizer, Body Butter with Infused Olive Oil, for Eczema, Rosacea, Baby (Lavender)

I’m a huge fan of anything that’s multi-use, and Dr. Bronner’s is a true MVP in our house. We’ve used it to wash baby, mix with water for foaming hand soap, clean counters, even make homemade bubble bath. I love that it’s organic, fair-trade, and made without artificial anything. It feels good knowing that I’m not coating my baby—or my home—in mystery ingredients. I usually get the unscented baby version and add my own lavender essential oil when I want a bit of calm.

3. Bath & Body

Baby wash – we actually use Dr. Bronner's Soap - Pure-Castile Soap for everything in our house! Laundry, Dishes, Hands. They make soap bars and liquid soaps and other cool products like toothpaste
Wool dryer balls – fragrance-free alternative to dryer sheets

4. Feeding

Breastfeeding:

Haakaa manual pump – catch letdown hands-free
Organic nipple balm: Earth Mama Nipple Butter
, Mummy’s Organics
Nursing bras – Pact is 100% organic cotton

Bottles:

Comotomo – medical-grade silicone
Lifefactory – glass with silicone sleeve
Phillips Avent Glass

Use a natural bottle brush + stainless steel drying rack (no BPA plastic)

I was blessed with milk supply so I never used bottles. But these are the best options that I found.

What Changed My Mind About Pacifiers

I didn’t plan on using a pacifier. I imagined I’d just nurse, cuddle, and everything would work itself out naturally. But then my first baby came—we could not go places as he hated car seats and always cried in a car. Nothing soothed him. I was exhausted, overwhelmed, and desperate. I remember the first time we tried a pacifier (after saying we never would)—he instantly calmed down. It felt like a miracle. From that moment on, I changed my view. Don't we all have stories like that?! When used mindfully, a natural rubber pacifier can be a game-changer for everyone’s sanity.

5. Pacifiers & Teething

FRIGG Natural Rubber Pacifiers
Ecopacifier is made from 100% pure rubber from the rubber tree
Wood or food-grade silicone teethers – Mushie is BPA Free
Pacifier clip – cloth or wood, no plastic parts

After having four kids, I was honestly tired of wearing stretched-out, synthetic clothes that never felt quite right. I wanted something soft, breathable, and non-toxic—but without paying $80 for a single tank top. That’s when I found Pact, and I can’t say enough good things.

Their clothing is 100% GOTS-certified organic cotton, and it’s actually affordable. I own their bras, underwear, maternity bike shorts, and soft everyday tees—and I reach for them daily. It’s the only brand I’ve found that checks all the boxes: comfortable, sustainable, stylish, and clean.

Wearing clothes that are kind to your skin feels like a small act of self-care—especially when your body is growing or healing from growing a whole human. Every mama deserves that. 💛

If you're building a non-toxic baby registry… don’t forget yourself. You matter too.

6. Clothing & Accessories

Organic Onesies & Sleepers – Burt’s Bees, Pact, Goumi
Swaddles:
Lightweight: Mushie Muslin Thick double-layer: Little Unicorn
Sleep sack – Woolino (merino wool), Halo organic cotton

Why I Love Baby Carriers

With four kids already and one more on the way, I’ve learned that babywearing is survival. It gives you your hands back—whether you're chasing toddlers, making lunch, or folding laundry. But more than that, it helps your baby feel safe and calm. There’s something magical about keeping your little one close to your heartbeat.

I personally love the Baby K’tan for those first newborn months. It’s soft, organic cotton (GOTS certified!) and easy to put on—no complicated wrapping.

Once baby grows, I switch to a sturdier structured carrier like ErgoBaby. It gives my back support, distributes weight evenly, and still allows baby to snuggle in. I only wish they offered an organic version on Amazon now.

There’s just no stroller or swing that replaces the closeness of a carrier. Honestly, my kids hated strollers. And for me, it’s one of those parenting tools that made a huge emotional difference too.

7. Gear & Travel

Britax car seat ClickTight Technology, we used Britax for older kids as well.
Momcozy Baby Carrier Natural Cotton Linen
Organic Baby K'tan Baby Carrier 100% GOTS Certified Cotton, easy to put on. Not a regular long scarf sling. I used it for babies 0-6 months. Then I switched to Ergobaby but I don't see organic options on Amazon now.

The picture below is what my Mom made me. I loved it so much but my baby grew out of that carrier fast.

Mama Needs Care Too

It's not just about the baby—you need care, too. Your body has done something miraculous, and recovery takes gentleness, time, and support. I’ve learned through five postpartum seasons that when I take care of myself, I show up more grounded and joyful for my family.

Some of my favorite postpartum comforts have been simple but powerful:

A warm sitz bath with herbs like chamomile, lavender, or calendula—it’s calming, healing, and just feels relaxing. I love the blends from Earth Mama and THENA.
A good organic tea with raspberry leaf, nettle, and oatstraw—it helped me feel nourished and supported hormonally in those early weeks.

8. Mama Care

Postpartum sitz bath blend – Earth Mama mix, THENA Natural Wellness Store or DIY herbs
Organic postpartum tea – Raspberry leaf, nettle, oatstraw
Nourishing snacks – Dates, bone broth, collagen, lactation cookies
Organic Cotton Postpartum Pads - LOLA
Multivitamin - I used Needed and it was approved by my midwife

And another recommendation is getting these stainless steel cups for toddlers/mama. We have tried many sippy cups from stores and they all went to trash in less than a year. These cups will last forever.

I used a midwife with all of my kids. And I do have another blog post with recommendations in Austin Area.

0 Comments